Antonio Galloni, Vinous Media. 93pts
"The 2012 Il Pino di Biserno is soft, succulent and absolutely beautiful. Mocha, raspberry jam, herb and cinnamon meld into a core of generous, resonant fruit as this inviting, super-expressive Maremma wine opens up in the glass. Silky, polished tannins round out the open-knit finish. Il Pino di Biserno is the prototypical Maremma red; ripe, sexy and absolutely delicious, with no hard edges and tons of early appeal. The 2012 is a real pleasure bomb"
BS, Wine Spectator. 92pts
"Bright cherry, cedar, herb, black pepper and leather flavors mark this concentrated, lush red. Remains rich and monolithic on the long finish. Should find a better balance in a few years. Sangiovese. Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot. Best from 2017 through 2023. 5,000 cases made"